I was recently gifted the re-release of the complete Star Wars Saga on Blu-ray disc.
First off let me say that this is probably my 4th version of the Saga (from VHS through DVD to Blu-ray) and I am always thrilled to watch it all over again.
Having said this I am left wondering if HD (High Definition) is really the right format for the Star Wars films. Personally I believe some things are best left alone. Although I strongly agree that a digital overhaul of the Saga was a necessity (The Special Edition and Episodes I thru III), I don’t believe HD has done it justice.
I know, you must be thinking I’m crazy. HD is “da bomb” these days and most films look incredible in this format. I have to say though the images in certain scenes look almost too “crystal clear”. One scene in particular is in The Empire Strikes Back. It’s the scene where the Imperial Star Destroyers are being overshadowed by Vader’s massive Super Star Destroyer. In my opinion, the ships look like they are just little models on a starry backdrop because the image detail is, well, too detailed!!!.
Sometimes using a filter or a “soft focus” can make things look more appealing and believable. Many directors use this method for obvious reasons. HD certainly takes some of that away. The hard edges in some scenes that use matte paintings (paintings on glass) for effects shots are simply downright harsh.
All in all it’s still worth watching again, if not for all the new goodies packaged with the release, but I’ll still be keeping my other copies…just in case I want to see it as I remember it…. a long time ago in a theatre far far away.